American Journal of Social Science Research
Articles Information
American Journal of Social Science Research, Vol.1, No.2, Jun. 2015, Pub. Date: May 28, 2015
Typology of Scientific Contestation and Consensus in Indonesian Community of the Social Studies for Building a Shared Paradigm
Pages: 101-113 Views: 1636 Downloads: 787
[01] Mohammad Imam Farisi, Study Program of Social Studies, Indonesian Open University, Surabaya Regional Center, Kampus C Universitas Airlangga, Mulyorejo, Surabaya, Indonesia.
One of the important milestones in epistemological discourse is the emergence of the idea that reality is not merely the result of a psychological and personal construction of an expert, but it rather a result of social construction that is built on a shared commitment among members of scientific discipline community. At this point, contestation towards a consensus on the scientific paradigm becomes an important and decisive part in any dynamics occurring within a discipline. It is a sociological prerequisite for the achievement of normal science, genesis and sustainability of a particular scientific tradition. This article examines and describes the typology of contestation-consensus in Indonesian community of social studies to establish a shared paradigm of the social studies as a "synthetic discipline". Based on the Shwed and Bearman’s model on "the temporal structure of scientific consensus formation,” this article shows that contestations in Indonesian community of social studies towards a consensus about social studies as a synthetic discipline is benign or flats, a typology of contestation and consensus in which there is no really scientific contestation or competition, and more likely to reflect of scientist’s ambition personally to exhibit the same exponential growth of papers but with flat (and low) contestation levels.
Scientific Contestation and Consensus, Social Studies Community, Sociology of Science, Shared Paradigm
[01] Abbott, A. (2001). Chaos of disciplines. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
[02] Adikusumo, S. (1989). Results of research on social studies. Unpublished research report, Education Consortium, Bandung. [IND]3
[03] Al-Muchtar, S. (1991). Development of thought skills and values in social studies: A socio-cultural study of education. Unpublised doctoral dissertation, Post Graduate Faculty of Education and Teacher Training, Bandung. [IND]
[04] Al-Muchtar, S. (2007). Social studies. In Education Development Team Faculty of Education, Indonesia University of Education (FIP-UPI). Science and education in applied (part 3: scientific discipline education, pp. 271-296). Bandung: IMTIMA. [IND]
[05] Barr, R. D., Barth, J. L., & Shermis, S.S. (1978). The nature of the social studies. Palm spring: An ETS Pablication.
[06] Barr, R.D., Barth, J.L., & Shermis, S.S. (1977). Defining the social studies. Virginia: National Council for the Social Studies.
[07] Belen, S. (2010). History of elementary curriculum in Indonesia. Jakarta: Puskur-Reseach and Development Agency the Ministry of Education and Culture. [IND]
[08] Berger, P.L., & Luckmann, T. (1966). The social construction of reality: A treatise in the sociology of knowledge. Harmondsworth. Middlesex. England: Penguin Books.
[09] Campbell, R.L. (2006). Jean Piaget's genetic epistemology: Appreciation and critique. Retrieved November 15, 2004, from
[10] Cooper, H. M. (1988). The structure of knowledge synthesis. Knowledge in Society, 1, 104-126.
[11] Cornbleth, C. 1985. Critical thought and cognitive processes. In W. Stanley (Ed.), Review of research in social studies education: 1976-1983 (pp. 11-64). New York: NCSS.
[12] Dewey, J. (1964). Democracy and education: An introduction to the philosophy of education. New York: McMillan Co.
[13] Dryden. (1956). Social foundations of education. New York: The Dryden Press, Inc.
[14] Evans, D., & Kowanko I. (2000). Literature reviews: Evolution of a research methodology. Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing, 18(2), 33-38.
[15] Evans, R.W. (2004). The social studies wars: What should we teach the children? US: Teachers College, Columbia University.
[16] Galvan, J. (2006). Writing literature reviews: A guide for students of the behavioral sciences (3rd ed.). Glendale, CA: Pyrczak Publishing.
[17] Geertz, C. (2013). The religion of Java: Red and white Moslem, bureaucracy in Javanese culture. Jakarta: Komunitas Bambu. [IND].
[18] Gibbons, M. et al (1994). The new production of scientific knowledge: The dynamics of science and research in contemporary society. London: Sage.
[19] Hartshorn, & Somantri, N. (1970). Challenges in teaching social sciences. Unpublished monograph, Bandung. [IND].
[20] Hasan, S.H. (1996). Social sciences education. Bandung: Department of History Education, Faculty of Social Studies, Institute of Education and Teacher Training. [IND].
[21] Hasan, S.H. (2010). Development of junior high-school curriculum (from Dutch East Indies, Japan occupation and independence age). Jakarta: Puskur-Reseach and Development Agency the Ministry of National Education. [IND].
[22] Hunt, M.P. & Metcalf, L.E. (1955). Teaching high school social studies: Problems in reflective thought and social understanding. New York: Harper & Brothers Publisher.
[23] Kenworthy, L.S. (1970). Guide to social studies Teaching. Belmont, California: Wadsworth Publishing Company, Inc.
[24] Kuhn. T.S. (1970). The structure of scientific revolutions (2nd ed., enlarged). London: The University of Chicago Press, Ltd.
[25] Longstreet, W.S., & Shane, H.G. (1993). Curriculum for a new millennium. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
[26] Mayring, P. (2000). Qualitative Content Analysis. Forum Qualitative Social Research, Vol. 1(2). Retrieved April 4, 2014, from
[27] Ministry of Education and Culture (Kemendikbud). (2012). Document of curriculum 2013. Jakarta: Puskur-Reseach and Development Agency. [IND]
[28] Ministry of Education and Culture (Kemendikbud). (2013). Curriculum 2013: Basic competencies for elementary school. Jakarta: Puskur-Reseach and Development Agency. [IND]
[29] Mongan-Rallis, H. (2012) Guidelines for writing a literature review. Retrieved December 5, 2012, from litreview.html
[30] Mulder, N. (1997). Individual, society and history according to Indonesian school texts. Yogyakarta: Kanisius. [IND]
[31] National Council for Social studies (NCSS). (1935). Social sciences as the core of the curriculum. Washington: NCSS.
[32] National Council for Social studies (NCSS). (1989). Charting a course: Social studies for the 21st century, a report of the curriculum task force of the national commission on social studies in the schools. Washington: NCSS.
[33] National Council for Social studies (NCSS). (1994). A vision of powerful teaching and learning in the social studies: Building social understanding and civic efficacy. Retrieved October 23, 2013 from
[34] National Council for Social studies (NCSS). (1994). Expectations of excellence: Curriculum standards for social studies. Washington, D.C.: NCSS.
[35] National Council for Social studies (NCSS). (2010). National curriculum standards for social studies: A framework for teaching, learning, and assessment. Silver Spring, MD: NCSS.
[36] National Council for Social studies (NCSS). 1994. Curriculum guidelines for social studies teaching and learning. Retrieved October 23, 2013, from
[37] National Departement of Education (Depdiknas). (2007). Academic manuscript on the study of social studies curriculum. Jakarta: Puskur-Reseach and Development Agency. [IND].
[38] Parsons, T. (1968). Intellectual specialization and compartmentalization. In T.O. Buford (Ed.), Toward a philosophy of education (pp.16-39). New York: Holt, Reinhart and Winston, Inc.
[39] Pierce, S. J. 1991. Subject areas, disciplines and the concept of authority. LISR-Library and Information Science Research, 13, 21-35.
[40] Popkewitz, T.S. & Maurice, H.St. (1991). Social studies education and theory: Science, knowledge, and history. In J.P. Shaver (Ed.), Handbook of research on social studies teaching and learning (pp. 27-40). New York: Macmillan Publishing Company.
[41] Popper, K. (1970). Normal science and its dangers, In I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave (Eds.), Criticism and the growth of knowledge (pp.51-58). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[42] Republik of Indonesia (RI). (1970). State Address President of Indonesia Generals Suharto at Assembly House of Representatives (DPRGR). Jakarta, August 16, 1970. Retrieved January 13, 2014, from [IND].
[43] Ritzer, G. (1992). Sociological theory (3rd ed.), Singapore: McGraw-Hill.
[44] Ritzer, G.. (1975). Sociology: A multiple paradigm science. The American Sociologist, 10(3), 156-167.
[45] Ross, E.W. (Ed.). (2006). The social studies: Curriculum purposes, problems, and possibilities, (3rd ed.), New York: SUNY Press, Albany.
[46] Russell, D.R. (1993). Vygotsky, Dewey, and externalism: Beyond the student/discipline dichotomy. Retrieved March 20, 2003, from
[47] Sanusi, A. (1971). Strengthening fundamentals of teaching social studies in Indonesia: Toward comprehensive system. Unpublished monograph, Bandung. [IND].
[48] Sanusi, A. (1998). Alternative education: Touching fundamental problems of education and social. D. Supriadi & R. Mulyana (Eds.), Bandung: Post Graduate Program, Institute of Education and Teacher Training - Grafindo Media Pratama. [IND].
[49] Saxe, D.W. (1991). Social studies in schools: A history of the early years. New York: State University of New York.
[50] Shils, E. (1981). The intellectuals. In D. Hartoko (Ed.). ”The intellectual groups: Those who have a home in the wind” (pp...........). Jakarta: PT. Gramedia. [IND].
[51] Shwed, U., & Bearman, P.S. (2010). The temporal structure of scientific consensus formation. American Sociological Review. 75(6), 817-840.
[52] Somantri, N. (2001). Initiating a renewal of the social studies. D. Supriadi & R. Mulyana (Eds.), Bandung: Post Graduate Program, University of Education & Remaja Rosdakarya. [IND].
[53] Strauss, J.D. (2012). Thomas Kuhn's concept of paradigm: Narrative displacement in history of science. Retrieved November 30, 2012 from Sumaatmadja, N. (2006). a perspective on study of social. Bandung: Alumni. [IND].
[54] Sundhaussen, U. (1986). Indonesian Military Policies 1945-1967: Toward Dual Function of Military. Jakarta: LP3ES. [IND].
[55] University of California Museum of Paleontology (UCMP). (2012). Understanding science: How science really works. Retrieved November 30, 2012 from Wesley, E.B. (1942). Teaching the social studies (2nd ed.), Boston: D.C. Heath and Company.
[56] Wesley, E.B. (1946). Teaching social studies in elementary schools. Boston: D.C. Heath and Company.
[57] Wesley, E.B., & Wronski, S.P. (1950). Teaching social studies in high schools (3rd ed.,) Boston: D.C. Heath and Company.
[58] Winataputra, U.S. (2001). Indentity of citizenship education as a systemic vehicle for democracy education: A conceptual study in social studies context. Unpublised doctoral dissertation, Post Graduate Program, Indonesia University of Education, Bandung. [IND].
[59] Winataputra, U.S. (2011). Dynamics in conceptualizing of social studies and citizenship education (civics) in primary and secondary education: A study in collective mindset in historical-epistemological domains. Journal of Education, 12(1):1-20. [IND].
MA 02210, USA
AIS is an academia-oriented and non-commercial institute aiming at providing users with a way to quickly and easily get the academic and scientific information.
Copyright © 2014 - 2017 American Institute of Science except certain content provided by third parties.